Editorial Expectations
Sharing your work with someone other than family and friends can be daunting. Somewhat of a moment of truth to get a fresh take on a story you’ve been working on for so long. But an editor’s job is to take the work that you’ve invested so much time and energy into and make critical suggestions for improvement. Try to look at it as the beginning of an ongoing conversation, where they’ll share their honest opinions and provide critique to make your story shine. So, let’s pivot and take a glance at the process from the editor’s point of view.
Editor’s Process
Just as every editor has a preference in books they are interested in, they all have a different approach to their projects. The majority of editors will ask for your manuscript in full. Others may ask for the first half, then send you an editorial letter that gives you time to glance over their suggestions and consider them. That decision may depend on how long the project is in word count. The processes may vary, so if you are curious, ask.
Editorial Letter
An organized note from your editor that can be anywhere from 1 to 5 pages long, depending on editorial suggestions. This letter goes over such things as character development, world-building, plot, diction, and overall technique. The letter allows you to get a better idea of how your editor is comprehending the project. It will include concrete edits (edits that your editor truly believes must be changed), suggestions, and explanations for both.
Communication
Your editor should never make you feel as if you are not allowed to ask questions about their suggestions. The edits that they give are mostly optional, with the understanding that the manuscript is still your project. The right editor, though, will be honest and direct with you about their edits. Most will fight for a necessary change. Your job in the editing process is to distinguish suggestions from necessary changes. If there is an edit that you do not understand, ask for a stronger explanation.
Developmental editing and copyediting should go hand in hand. Learn more about another step in the editing process on the next page.